257 Sugarloaf Street

257 Sugarloaf Street
257 Sugarloaf Street
257 Sugarloaf Street
+42
4
 bed
1
 bath
6
 parking
1500 - 2000
 sqft
Detached
$639,900
For Sale
27 days
 on site
$639,900
Click to open the pre-gallery to get the direction
Size
-
Lot size
9521 sqft
Street frontage
-
Possession
Immediate
Price per sqft
$320 - $427
Taxes
$3,770.8 (2024)
Parking Type
-
Style
2-Storey
See what's nearby
Description
*The Old Mill House* Discover timeless charm in an unbeatable location! Situated directly across from Lake Erie, HH Knoll Park, and the picturesque Sugarloaf Marina, this well-maintained classic home is just a short stroll to Historic West Street and the vibrant heart of downtown. Renowned for its stunning curb appeal and inviting front porch, this home showcases its rich character through beautifully preserved details like wood doors, trim, baseboards, and flooring. The spacious living room is bathed in natural light from large paned windows during the day, complemented by cozy pot lights in the evening. A formal dining room, accessed through double French doors, leads to a modernized kitchen featuring a breakfast bar and convenient access to the backyard. The elegant wood staircase ascends to four generously sized bedrooms, offering plenty of space for family and guests. With over 1,600 sq. ft. of living space, the property also includes an unfinished attic, accessible by staircase, presenting exciting potential for additional living or recreational space. Nestled on a 160 deep lot, the home boasts landscaped gardens, interlock pathways, and a spacious backyard shaded by mature trees. The rear Breakwater Laneway leads to a one-car garage, with parking access from both Steele Street and Isabel Street. Recent updates include a new roof in 2023, ensuring peace of mind for years to come. Dont miss your chance to own this stunning piece of history in a prime lakeside setting!
Broker: RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE
MLS®#: X12044116
Open House Times
Sunday, Apr 27th
12:30pm - 2:30pm
Add to calendar
Property details
Parking:
6
Parking type:
-
Property type:
Detached
Heating type:
Water
Style:
2-Storey
MLS Size:
1500-2000 sqft
Lot front:
59 Ft
Lot depth:
160 Ft
Listed on:
Mar 27, 2025
Show all details
Rooms
LevelNameSizeFeatures
Main
Dining Room
16.0 x 12.0 ft
Second
Bedroom 4
10.0 x 10.0 ft
Second
Bedroom 3
12.0 x 12.0 ft
Show all
Instant estimate:
orto view instant estimate
$49,807
lower than listed price
i
High
$624,775
Mid
$590,093
Low
$566,951
129 Durham Street
1/14
$689,000
9 days
129 Durham Street
6BD
4BA
4 Parking
1,500-2,000 sqft
MLS#: X12080125
REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage
9 days
130 Killaly Street
1/38
$699,900
105 days
130 Killaly Street
6+2BD
4BA
6 Parking
1,500-2,000 sqft
MLS#: X11913945
RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE
105 days
41 Amelia Street
1/31
$699,900
8 days
41 Amelia Street
3BD
4BA
2 Parking
1,500-2,000 sqft
MLS#: X12080773
ROYAL LEPAGE STATE REALTY
8 days
477 Bell Street
1/42
$629,900
18 days
477 Bell Street
5+1BD
3BA
3 Parking
1,500-2,000 sqft
MLS#: X12063804
RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE
18 days

About 257 Sugarloaf Street

Located at 257 Sugarloaf Street, this Port Colborne detached house is available for sale. 257 Sugarloaf Street has an asking price of $639900, and has been on the market since March 2025. This detached house has 4 beds, 1 bathroom and is 1500-2000 sqft.

For groceries or a pharmacy you'll likely need to hop into your car as there is not much near this detached house.

If you are looking for transit, don't fear, there is a Bus Stop (Flag Stop / Elm St / Charlotte S) only a 5 minute walk.